Showing posts with label Disraeli. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Disraeli. Show all posts

Sunday, 22 December 2019

There is no such thing as social conservatism, there is just conservatism



Since the recent general election there has been an outbreak of writing about a thing called "social conservatism" best summed up in observations about tactical positioning for political campaigns - "move a little left economically and a little right socially". I am, if you forgive me, just a little bemused about this argument and how it has been characterised using a qualified depiction of conservatism. It's as if we can't take the whole package of conservative ideas, just the 'social' bits.

In one respect this terminology has allowed those inherently opposed to conservatism - liberals, fascists, socialists and communists - to attack the idea by describing 'social conservatism' as variously racist, sexist, homophobic and backward looking. This is mostly done by those opposing forces choosing to define conservatism negatively ('social conservatism is anti-immigrant', 'social conservatism is authoritarian', 'social conservatism is anti-LGBT') thereby allowing them to hack away at a convenient straw bogeyman.

The problem is that (and this is the source of my bemusement) there is no such thing as social conservatism, there is just conservatism. It's the idea that we're all in this boat called Britain together and we'd better get along, trust each other and work together if we're going to make a decent fist of the place. It's the idea - as Kipling told us - that, much though we want and try to love the whole world, "our hearts are small" and we focus on the places we know and love most. When people use the misleading term 'social conservatism' they are simply describing this central idea for conservatives - it is a reminder that conservatism doesn't see economics as the all-defining idea of human progress in the way that liberalism (and its corrupted half-brother socialism) see it.

Unsurprisingly Kenan Malik, writing in the Observer, engages in both of these falsehoods - creating that straw bogeyman and characterising social conservatism as somehow distinct from other forms of conservatism:
Working-class wariness of immigration is not an expression of an innate social conservatism but of the loss of trust, the breaking of social bonds and a sense of voicelessness. Working-class lives have been made more precarious not just through material deprivation, but through the erosion of the more intangible aspects of their lives – their place in society, the sense of community, the desire for dignity.
Malik suggests, in what John Duffield on Twitter called "Left wing "orientalism" towards conservatism", that the working class is not socially conservative because we shouldn't "...confuse anger at social atomisation and political voicelessness with social conservatism."

The problem here is that the loss of trust and those intangible things Malik describes - place, community, dignity - are the very things that conservatives wrestle with most. This is what Disraeli wrote about in Sybil - the idea of 'two nations' and the need to bring them together, the sense that the industrial revolution, for all its advances, had left a fragmented society - "atomised" to use Malik's word. Disraeli, as a conservative, had a closer understanding of the social purpose of Chartism than liberals or socialists because he put the need to improve the condition of the working man - socially as much as economically - as the central purpose of his conservatism.

For all the talk of policy platforms and proposals, the big challenges facing us are less economic than they are social - the decline in fertility, the rise in loneliness, cities filled with single people, the loss of trust in each other, the collapse of vital institutions like marriage and the family, and the focus on paid work as the only valued thing in society. Put these alongside a sense that we've lost the idea of personal responsibility, that chivalry is disdained and that we all have rights but not duties, and there's a clear description of the conservative imperative for change.

I don't know whether Boris Johnson's government will be able - or even intends - to start the process of rebuilding trust, strengthening communities and promoting personal responsibility and duty, but I do know that this is what we mean by conservatism. Yes it is, for reason of Kipling's small hearts, patriotic. Yes it is supportive of marriage and families because they're the base units of society. And yes it likes faith and the idea of the transcendent. But it is also right there with the idea of giving people voice, supporting communities and giving support to the vulnerable. The Conservative Party - an often uneasy alliance between liberals and conservatives - may not always put these ideas centre and front, we certainly didn't (at least rhetorically) during the Thatcher years, but this does not make them any less central to the ideology of conservatism.

It is ironic that "there is no such thing as society" became embedded in the left's idea of conservatism to such an extent that the truth of it - that society is built of "individual men and women" and "families" (the rest of Margaret Thatcher's quotation) - is lost. Thatcher's comment represents the balancing act in her party between liberalism and conservatism by putting the idea of society in the context of both individualism and families. What conservatives don't (which socialists and fascists do) see is that society is greater than the sum of its parts, it is a means to an end not an end in itself. And conservatives also believe that the institutions of society should, wherever possibly, be human in scale, accessible to all and trusted.

It was welcome that, on Disraeli's birthday, James Cleverly the Conservative Party Chairman shared some of his ideas. We seem to have escaped from a deadening, almost unhuman utilitarianism, the cold emotionless Hayekian world, and returned to where conservatives began, with the idea that community matters, that the base institutions of society like family, marriage and faith need protecting and preserving, and that our purpose is to make the lives of ordinary people better.

....

Monday, 25 July 2011

A loud celebration of being right wing...

Disraeli - a great right winger!
I am a Conservative to preserve all that is good in our constitution, a Radical to remove all that is bad. I seek to preserve property and to respect order, and I equally decry the appeal to the passions of the many or the prejudices of the few. (Benjamin Disraeli)

A while back I penned a little joyful celebration of being “Tory Scum”:

For me, yelling “Tory Scum, Here We Come” is an admission once again of socialism’s defeat. There is no rational, intelligent argument in this dystopic, dehumanising creed’s favour so its advocates must resort to insult – to hurling abuse, to fear, aggression and destruction as a substitute for debate and discussion.
Socialism died in 1989 – us “Tory Scum” were proved right. And when I hear it now, I smile.

I forgot, in writing this, that there is a wider problem for the failure that is Labour – the need to condemn its enemy, anyone who disagrees with the numbing, controlling, interfering, mistrusting and uncaring “democratic socialism”. And the way this is done is – along with thinking it cool to attack people personally for believing in free markets and independence – to use the dread term “right wing”. Especially when that term can link free marketer libertarians with state-loving fascists.

The problems with this position are two-fold – firstly, it represents an act of desperation by social democrats. The term “right wing” represents (in the mind of the social democrat) all that is bad an evil – Mussolini, Hitler, Franco, Pinochet, these are the incarnate representatives of what it means to right wing. And it is but a short journey from not actually supporting social democracy to building gas chambers or machine gunning children.

Secondly – and most importantly – Fascism, in whatever incarnation we chose, is not right-wing but is the bastard child of Fabian social democracy. Yes the social democracy was corrupted, forced into a marriage with militarism (rather as we see with Castro, with Ortega and with Chavez) and made to serve aggressive nationalism. But, in the end, it is socialism – the idea that the state could perfect man – that sits in the middle of fascism. No observer free from the left’s prejudice could describe National Socialism as ‘right wing’.

So let us rescue being right wing from this corrupted view of the left wing commentariat, let us set out what is really means to be right wing:

·         For the right “caring” doesn’t mean raising taxes from the relatively poor, paying them to middle class professionals who then ‘care’ for the poor. Caring is something we do personally – it is an individual act, done without looking to a nice salary and an index-linked public pension. Right wingers do not view charity as a sin
·         Right wing people seek out independence and self-reliance – our aspiration is to provide for ourselves, to care (that word again) for our families, to look out for our friends and to pay our way in the world without recourse to the support of the state
·         As right wingers we do not see the words ‘business’ and ‘enterprise’ as problematic or slippery  terms only salvageable through the appending of the word ‘social’ – these words are central of belief that, left to their own devices, people will take advantage of the market’s natural laws to better themselves and, in doing so, better society
·         Right wing people recognise the importance of place – not as something to be managed, let alone created, by the agents of government but as the mud on our boots, the soil in which we have settled and grown strong. And the right to own that place – to be able to use our property as we see fit – is essential to that understanding. Place without private property is serfdom
·         And lastly those of us on the right doubt and question the role and purpose of government. It is not simply to echo Ronald Reagan’s joke – the most frightening words in the English Language, “I from the government and I’m here to help”- but to believe that independence, enterprise and the busy-ness of hard work are driving betterment and that the state is, most of the time, a barrier to a better place, a better society and happier people

This is what is means to be right wing. It is to be celebrated not muttered secretly behind our hands in case some BBC executive or Guardian columnist hears and points the finger crying; "look they admit to being right wing, they must be stopped before terrible things happen".

And those terrible things? Ah yes – peace, freedom, democracy, self-reliance, independence and the ownership of place.

Whatever the Guardian and the BBC may say, whatever lies they made spread, never forget....

...being right wing is good, you’re helping save the world from the controlling state, you’re making it better, cleaner, wealthier and safer for everyone.

 ....