Showing posts with label coronavirus. Show all posts
Showing posts with label coronavirus. Show all posts

Sunday, 19 July 2020

You've not been to the pub yet have you? The price of creating fear.


So I'm having a haircut, first since February, and chatting to the barber. I've known him since he opened his first barbers over the road from my house about 20 years ago. We were (I suspect like plenty of others) talking lightly about the current pandemic, its effect on businesses and on behaviour.

"So, Simon. You been to the pub yet?"

"Yep, I was there on the first day they re-opened."

The chat continued in this vein - the barber was in the same camp as me but a little concerned about getting caught in a local lockdown (and the resulting closing of his business again). But he confirmed to me a feature of this re-opening - that a lot of people are putting off going back to the pub or out to a restaurant: "going to leave it a bit" seems to be a common response. It is interesting too that this attitude seems to be more prevalent among younger people, the sort who you'd expect to provide the bedrock of business for a lot of pubs and restaurants.

I'd had this sort of conversation with others - Jo who runs The George in Cullingworth said it had been really quiet since they re-opened (we were there for a meal) and the people who I play RPGs with on-line are all mostly in the "I'm not risking it yet" camp. None of these folk are in the "Anybody Going to a Pub is a Terrible Person who Will Bring About a Second Peak" category you witness on social media sites but they all pretty much buy the idea that the second peak is a real, even likely thing, and therefore sitting home for a while longer is the way to go.

Hardly a day passes without another report of a high street restaurant or pub chain going into liquidation, receivership or announcing restructuring. Just today my local paper had two of these - from Bistrot Pierre and the owners of Pizza Express and Zizzi. We've seen pub chains close, restaurants shuttered and fast food groups clobbered. The hope had been that, once we were allowed out to eat and drink, even with the 'social distancing' controls, the result would be a flood of custom for these businesses. It hasn't happened and I fear for the future of many, for the livelihoods of thousands, and for the job prospects of millions.

Twitter though can always be relied on for a unique take on not going out to a pub or a restaurant. I challenged one person who tweeted this from their Cornish holiday let: "(w)ell, we don’t want to go inside pubs or restaurants, so we’ll make our own private bar and eating area for the week". I observed that this seemed to reflect the triumph of fear and would mean pubs and restaurants dying and got this back:


So somebody who isn't ill or affected by this virus decides not to go out for a meal when on holiday because other people might be frightened? And it's like saving the planet (or something). Anyway I asked for an explanation because it didn't make sense for someone who wasn't fearful, wasn't in a risk category and wasn't ill to stay at home to "minimise" their impact.



Got it? If you read the words it is clear that this isn't about compassion at all but about avoiding people whose "lives may be serious(ly) impacted by this virus". You can, if you like, see this as 'love and compassion' but it looks to me like a strange rationalising of what can only be called fear - fear of catching the virus, fear of the 'second peak'. And it is this fear that, right now, presents an existential threat to businesses like pubs, cafes, bars and restaurants plus all people who supply them and the jobs of people who work in them.

If we want a high street left, if we want the local pub to stay open, if we want seaside cafes and country inns, then at some point we have to stop being scared witless at the prospect of either getting the virus or creating this much talked of 'second peak'. What we see though is inconsistency everywhere - from ministers, oppostition, media and public bodies. The roadside is still brightened by flashing signs telling us to stay at home, local councils issue portentious press statements about how it's not safe out there, and ministers flip flop between get back to normal and don't go out if you don't have too it's bad out there. All urged on by opposition and media more interested in news ratings or opinion polling than the future of high street businesses, pubs, bars and restaurants.

I write this, not to have a go at those who fear going back to the pub, but to get across that our leaders - public, business, cultural - need to step up and start getting people to reassess the basis of their fears. The personal risk from the virus is very small right now (not nothing and the thing hasn't burnt itself out) especially if you are young and healthy, but near every public pronouncement is couched in terms designed to reinforce the heightened level of worry and fret created to ensure high levels of compliance with lockdown and social distancing. Until officials, ministers, councillors and media folk start saying it's safe - or at least that your chance of getting infected with the virus is very small and the chance of you being very ill with it smaller still - then we'll continue to see people opting for a rickety table and some canvass chairs on a patio rather than a little local restaurant or the corner benches in the pub round the corner. And that restuarant and the pub may just end up going bust.

...





Friday, 5 June 2020

The 'new normal' is a victory for public sector fussbuckets and worrywarts. I hate it.


Between the rain showers, we went for a walk yesterday. Our route took us, pretty much, round the edge of the village and we ran into a few folk, had a few conversations. it was pleasant and, as we stepped back home, the sun was shining, birds sang and it all seemed pretty good. A fine June day you might say.

I got to thinking about those conversations and some of the things people said make me worry. Not one friend we met whose business has been completely trashed by the lockdown and associated restrictions - "we're not expecting to have any business at all this year" was the rough analysis. I suspect this message will be repeated again and again as small businesses in hospitality, entertainment, events management and travel ponder a future that is probably more terrifying than the folk planning our post-coronavirus world imagine.

No it's not just these folk or the thousands of small traders - shops, pubs, market stalls, concert venues and suppliers to all these good folk - who will shut up shop because they can't make the ongoing restrictions work for their business and their customers. Lot's of people will watch as their big national and multinational competitors, often those who've agitated for ongoing restrictions, suck up business while they wonder where their next work is coming from. Pub landlords will look in anger at Wetherspoons opening their huge cavernous boozers, able to run table service apps and queuing systems that are literally impossible for a little local pub.

No it's not just these folk, nor is it the annoyance at Bradford council badging Goit Stock falls as a top ten destination when there's no parking, no provision for visitors. It's a great place and I love it but the villages can't cope when hundred's arrive from across the North because the Council thoughtlessly describes it as a place to visit, a destination. This is the same Council that closed all its parks for no good reason, has done nothing to open its museums and galleries, and prefers virtue-signalling with coloured lights on City Hall to helping local folk get on.

But no, it's not that either. The thing that troubled me most was a throwaway remark - "we'll lose all the benefits of lockdown". I didn't say anything but, you know, there are a whole lot of people out there who think lockdown is great. From the "nature is healing" nutcases through to those who like the fact that travel restrictions, closed pubs and silenced cafes made their village "more peaceful". I worry that these voices, along with a new collection of people made terrified of every cough or sniffle, will prevail and the restrictions will remain.

The 'new normal' they call it. A world with a new set of petty restrictions and controls. A whole new bunch of rules for the worst sort of local councillor to get excited about enforcing. An avalanche of regulations, bans and vaguely worded control orders for police and pretend police to wave in the faces of people doing nothing worse than enjoying themselves in what jumped up jobsworths and worrywarts think is the wrong way or at the wrong time.

We'll see a load more access and parking restrictions making city centres the exclusive playground of their own residents rather than destinations. Or, in the case of failing centres like Bradford, a desert of empty shops, increasingly derelict buildings and half-let offices, all interspersed by the grand regeneration projects funded by slabs of central government cash or rash unsistainable council borrowing. Projects that allow local leaders to pretend that it's all fine, that the place isn't dying, and that this magic bit of government cash will make all the difference.

The high status public sector people in towns like Bradford will cluster round the few remaining successes, telling each other that this is the start of a renaissance, that it's all great, and that those pointing to the emptiness, decline and dereliction are just 'talking down the city'. And then the public sector elite return to their day jobs planning response to climate change, designing regulations and limits on business, and dreaming up new ways to marshal people so as to maintain "social distancing". There's no place in their world for the slightly rough suburban pub with its karaoke, quiz night and occasionally raucous behaviour. No place for cheap weddings or a tray of butties and pies for a funeral tea. No place for crowds (or at least not the wrong sort of crowds).

Everywhere I hear people telling me it won't be the same again. And every time I hear this, a little piece of me dies. The idea that we make illegal - regulate away - the pub filled to bursting on bonfire night or packed with happy football fans fills me with sadness. The thought that, as the rain breaks up a June day, people can't crowd into a high street cafe, laughing and buying cake while they wait for the skies to clear. This is the world those advocating a "new normal" want to destroy, all in the name of a hypothetical risk and the deranged idea that government can make us safe by regulation.

A semi-lockdown badged as the "new normal" will not merely destroy the leisure economy but will signal that only approved leisure and pleasure is allowed. Welcome to a world where a cafe is full with a dozen people, where theatres remove half their seats so they can open, where everyone is encouraged to wander round in jerry-built, home-made hazmat suits, and where the hug, the high five and the scrum at the bar on a Saturday night are things of the past. Welcome to a new authoritarian world filled with tracking apps, cameras, face recognition and thousands of gauleiters eager to help enforce this drab, soulless and depressing world.

So no, I don't want your 'new normal'. I will rebel where I can, campaign where I am able to get it changed and keep shouting that this is not right and is destroying so much that is good about our country. I would say that the government has failed us but the truth is that government always, regardless of rhetoric or supposed ideology, wants more controls, more limits and more power over the lives of ordinary people. Coronavirus gave those fussbuckets, worrywarts and jobsworths the chance to get these controls and they absolutely love it.

....


Friday, 29 May 2020

Overcrowded housing made coronavirus worse.


Inside Housing have looked in some detail at the correlation between mortality from COVID-19 and housing crisis issues (shared housing, overcrowding, density). The full review is well worth a read - excellent journalism combining evidence, analysis and real human stories. Here's a few things to take away - firstly a graph:

For once (maybe the FT should take note) the graph isn't trying to prove a predetermined point, it simply shows that the more overcrowding - data from ONS and NOMIS - you have the higher the levels of COVID-19 mortality. Inside Housing go on to show the correlation extends through numbers of 'houses in multiple occupation' (HMOs), homelessness and social housing waiting lists.

It's no surprise to see that there's a relationship between cramped housing and infection rates, we see similar evidence from Singapore and New York. And other badly hit places like Madrid and Barcelona also have very overcrowded housing with associated health issues. People in these communities aremore likely to be sharing with a vulnerable person, more likely to work in crowded and exposed environments (food service, construction, transport), and more likely to rely on public transport.

It's become commonplace to point at population density as the problem but, as demographer Wendell Cox has streesed, the issue isn't population per se but rather what he calls "exposure denity", the number of close interactions with others that people have in an average day. It's clear that the poorest people in large cities are those most exposed and that two generations or more of inadequate, selfish and NIMBY-driven housing policies have been a big factor making this worse.

It's also worth noting that poor housing miught also be part of the reason for disproportionate mortality and infection among non-white minorities - Inside Housing remind us that while only 2% of UK households are overcrowed, the proportion rises to 30% for Bangladeshi households (15% for Pakistani and Black African).

I hope that, in the reaction to this clear correlation between mortality rates from COVD-19 and poor housing conditions, we begin to think about the reasons why places like London persist with high rates of overcrowding (efforts under the previous London mayor managed to push the rate down slightly but it is now rising again). Partly this is about "affordable" housing but in many respects this is a false lead - the real reason the rent's too damned high is because there is too liitle housing of all kinds. Awful decisions (by the council and the High Court) to refuse developments for too few affordable homes miss the point - yes, we need a more social housing but if a deveolment doesn't provide this accomodation is still contributes to the overall housing stock reducing housing pressures.

At the same time I'd like to see councils in inner London as well as campaign groups like Shelter start to put more pressure on government to reform urban containment policies such as the green belt and to reduce the power of NIMBYs (a minority everywhere but a vocal, influential one) to dictate local planning policies and decisions. Linked to better funding streams for social housing (support access to investment markets, allow greater flexibility on rents and a clearer grant system) this could result in better housing all round. And if delivering more housing choise, more equitable housing and healthier homes requires us to take up a few Surrey golf courses, some redundant airfield and marginal pasture land on the edge of small towns or villages with good connections to the big city, that's a small price for having a city where thousands don't die because where they live is so awful.


...


Wednesday, 27 May 2020

People don't want the fussbuckets' "New Normal", they want their lives back. And soon.


No hugs. No handshakes. No crowed pubs. No live music. No packed football terrace on a cold February night singing support. No theatre. No garden parties. No crammed cafe filled with people sheltering from summer rain. No school concert. No five-a-side football. No knock-about cricket in the park. No choral music. No midnight mass. No hard miles down the gym. No funeral party at the club with cuddles, remembering and shared love. No wetting the babies head. No quizzes in the old way with heads huddled together round a pub corner table. No piling to the local after a game of football, cricket or rugby. No drinks in a buzzing bar after a show. No comedy shows. No crawls round town with your mates. No nightclubs. No dancing. No children's party at the village hall. No scouts and guides. No kids pushing to the front to get the best view. No fireworks party. No New Years drinks in the village inn. No birthday pizza and drinks. No nights out with the guys from work. No popping into the pub after a walk to stand at the bar chatting to whoever will listen.

I am worried, upset, genuinely scared that the "new normal" everyone talks about means many of these curses of lockdown won't go away. There's a new battalion of worrywarts, fussbuckets, sneaks, snitches, self-righteous nannies and know-alls all set to impose their " new normal":
"I think it's going to be very very difficult for us to return to any of us standing at the bar or any of us mingling in a cafe indoors in a way that we have in the past,"
So proclaimed one of these worrywarts, Michael Gove. Not "it might be a while" but "very very difficut to return to". If this is true then you can probably measure my box or find me a ticket to a place where you can get back to normal because it's not a world I want. Nor was it the deal we signed up to when the government, back in March, sent us into lockdown. That deal was that lockdown was needed to make sure the NHS wasn't overwhelmed. It was not a plan to close down our lives until such a time as we either die or the government deems us fit to share a space over a drink, do some exercise or a million other things with friends, neighbours and family.

I read, can't remember where, about a pub that opened to serve takeaways. And, while folk were waiting for a meal, the landlord would sell you a bottle of beer to enjoy in the garden. Great idea, a business trying to survive and folk getting the chance to sit awhile with a pint. But for those snitches, sneaks and worrywarts this wasn't good enough, they complianed and the place got visits from police, trading standards, planning enforcement and anyone else the fussbuckets could rope in to stop this terrible thing - having a few folk sat in a garden enjoying a beer while waiting to pick up some dinner.

I've played the game. I've clapped for the NHS. I've spend a fortnight without leaving the house. I've socially distanced. (But believe me I'd have broken the lockdown in a breath if a friend or family needed help). It's time now to stop saying "thank you" for my effort and start returning me - and millions of others - to a normal life. One where children go to school. One where gyms and pubs are open. One where I can sit in a games cafe and play D&D. One where there are places to visit with nice cafes and a country pub for a drink and a meal. Not the nannying fussbuckets' "new normal" but the old normal, the one we set aside for a short time out of neighbourliness and solidarity.

Just open the pubs damn it. Let's have our lives back, let's end this lockdown. Above all let's not create a false impression that somehow because your cute Norfolk village is quiet, that makes lockdown anything other than an oppressive, controlling restriction on our lives. Yes, there really are some who see it as a sort of blessing (I guess they have money, jobs, business unaffected by the closures, and lives that don't involve social interaction):
So the effects of Covid-19 and the lockdown will be short-lived, though the inevitable recession has already begun to bite. Everyone will have less money, many will be jobless, taxes and prices will surely rise, yet I doubt if even those things will push us back into the peace and gentleness of lockdown. It has been a different world, and though it will be wonderful for so many to get outside freely again and for everyone to be reunited with family and friends, surely we will feel sadness and regret for our weeks in yet another lost world?
The "peace and gentleness of lockdown". Enough of this nonsense. Just open the pubs. Give us our lives back.

...