Showing posts with label opinion polling. Show all posts
Showing posts with label opinion polling. Show all posts

Tuesday, 27 August 2013

In which the BBC trolls Councillors for a story...

****

I got a nice email from polling company ComRes asking me to answer a few questions. As Guido reports, these questions amount to trolling for a story:

The questions include:
  • asking if they think “climate change is not happening”
  • whether “Immigration has had a negative impact on Britain”
  • whether “legalising gay marriage will cost my party more votes than it gains at the next Election”
  • whether they support a ban on the burkha
  • whether Cameron and Osborne are “arrogant”
  • whether they support an electoral pact with UKIP

I suppose it's funny in a way - and there will be some colleague who hold some pretty whack views - but the BBC, who commissioned this, really should be ashamed of such a blatant attempt to troll for a nice silly season story using an opinion poll (paid for with tax money).

....

Thursday, 5 May 2011

What a surprise....

****




More than half of all councillors think communities secretary, Eric Pickles, is doing a bad job, according to a new poll by Total Politics magazine.

The poll revealed that 52% think he is doing a bad job, while 33% think Mr Pickles has done a very or fairly good job since taking office last May.

But while all of the Labour councillors surveyed thought the communities secretary had done a bad job, 61% of Tories thought he had done a good job.

This perhaps qualifies for stupid poll of the week!

....




Monday, 27 December 2010

Why I hate English Literature!

Its funny isn’t it, those things which we get chippy about! And the sheer hypocrisy of such chippiness. However, this blogpost is about my shoulder-based chip and why it is important.

My chip is with English literature. Not the books themselves – although if I’m honest, I have tried and failed to read those books beloved of English teachers. I’ve set out to read a Jane Austen novel or two, I’ve struggled through a few chapters of assorted Brontë sisters writing and I’ve banged my head against D H Lawrence. All without success – I can find no joy or pleasure from such reading.

Nor do I find more recent writings any better – I waded my way through ‘Midnight’s Children’ although to this day I’m not entirely sure why I ploughed on through the indulgent, impenetrable prose as it gave me no satisfaction. And I could go on – every now and again one sets oneself to read one of these books so praised by the cognoscenti. And the result is inevitable disappointment.

So this is my chip. The intelligent press and media whenever it speaks of literature, speaks of these books. And I feel the weight of arrogant, smug, superiority from these literati – the clear impression that they are so much cleverer, so vastly more impressive since they can speak the language of “English Literature”!

So when I write words like this I mean them:

They don’t want to bury themselves in what some smug literary critic (in this case from the Guardian) calls “thought-provoking books” because, to put it pretty bluntly, most of the literary novels that clutter up the prize shortlists are really dull. A little bit of me smiles with pleasure at the fact that Katie Price (or rather whoever wrote the book with her name on) outsells the entire Booker shortlist!

This isn’t inverted snobbery – I don’t think that the potboilers churned out under Ms Price’s name are great books. But equally, I do not believe that a great book is defined by a narrow, self-referencing audience such as that which decides upon the Booker Prize shortlist and, ultimately, that prize’s winner. Such writing shoves aside – and the cognoscenti dismiss – whole areas of writing as mere ‘genre fiction’. No science fiction or fantasy book has ever graced the Booker shortlist for the simple reason that those who decide on that list believe no good writing exists within that genre (and more to the point wouldn’t be caught admitting to reading any of it).

I recall an especially snide article on science fiction in The Spectator. What struck me wasn’t that the author was snide – he’s entitled be so – but that it was abundantly clear that he hadn’t read a single SF novel and was basing his dismissal of the genre entirely on having watched a few mainstream science fiction TV shows and films.

So yes, one of my favourite TV moments will always be the expression of utter disappointment on Clive Anderson’s face when he had to announce that “The Lord Of The Rings” was the greatest English novel (or so the public had voted). And I smile serenely at some of the frothing antagonism (and allegations that the books vote was somehow fixed by hordes of “well-organised” Tolkien fans) that followed. Like from some writer I’d never heard of called O’Hagan:


O'Hagan, who was shortlisted for the 1999 Booker Prize with his novel Our Fathers, expressed anger that the show is based upon public opinion.

"Somebody said that The Big Read was not just un-literary but anti-literary and I think that's right," he said. "It is based on the assumption that the opinion of the public is always beyond reproach."

O'Hagan added that he "hated the opinion of the population".

"Their choice in books is bound to be emetic, and so it has proved to be."

You do see why we hate the literary establishment now don’t you?

....

Wednesday, 10 March 2010

Abstentions set to top General Election Poll Again!

***
Have avoided writing about polls and such like – partly because while I may be obsessed with them most normal folk are not. But mostly because Anthony Wells does such a great job reporting on them that what I add is usually pretty marginal.

However, I was struck by the front page headline in Metro this morning – “Labour loses third of voters”. Now before you all make jokes about Gordon’s carelessness, let’s look at the body of the report which relates to the findings of a Harris Poll for the paper:



“Just 66 per cent of those who backed labour in 2005 intend to vote for the party now, the research showed. It compared with 86 per cent of Conservative supporters who say they will back the party again. The Liberal Democrats have also shed a third of their 2005 voters according to our poll.”


Let’s be clear, if this is literally true that is over 6 million voters who are switching to a voting behaviour other that that in 2005. Polls suggest that about about 1m additional people are planning on voting Conservative. The Liberal Democrat polling figures are all over the place but the poll reported here puts them down 4 point on 2005 – about 1 million votes. And Labour have dropped about 1.5 million on 2005.

We still have 3 million missing voters – people who will not be voting for the main three parties. The Harris Poll shows “others” at 16% - that’s up about 1.5 million votes. So what’s happened to those other 1.5 million votes – about 6% of the electorate?

My guess is they won’t be voting. Expect turnout to drop to its lowest for some while – probably around 55%.

Looks like the good idiots are on course to top the poll come May!

...

Wednesday, 3 February 2010

Maybe there's a real shift in English politics? And will the Conservatives spot it?

***

The wholly admirable UK Polling Report presents some analysis of MORI’s 2009 polling figures and makes this observation:

“This pattern of swing, with voters in groups that traditionally support Labour swinging the most strongly toward the Conservatives, produces a truly startling pattern when we get to MORI’s breaks by type of seat. MORI have the Conservative lead in Lab-v-Con seats with a Labour majority of under 8.7% of 21 points. Depending on exactly what notional figures MORI used and how they treated three way marginals, that represents a swing of around about 12.5%. Looking at Lab-v-Con seats with majorities up to 13.9% the Conservative lead is still 21 points – suggesting an even bigger swing in those seats (somewhere around 14%).

If the Conservative swing is biggest in Lab-v-Con marginals it must be lower elsewhere. It isn’t in safe Labour seats, MORI suggest a swing of 13% there. Part of it is Lib Dem seats, where the swing from Labour to the Conservatives is less than 1% (the swing from LD to Con is 7.4%, but I suspect that under-represents how well the Lib Dems would actually do). Where the big swings in Labour seats are really balanced out seems to be in the Tory heartlands – in seats the Conservatives already hold MORI’s figures only suggest a swing from Labour of 5%.”

To paraphrase – the voters in upper middle class England are not swinging to the Conservatives but those in lower middle class and (dare I say it) working class England are switching to the Tories. Now Anthony Wells at UK Polling Report adds the caveat that:

"Previous elections have never shown differential swings of this degree, we simply don’t get swings of 5% in one type of seat and 14% in another.!"

…but it might, just might suggest a real shift in English politics (and Anthony suggests this too). A shift where ordinary, working class folk who work in the private sector, don’t earn a great deal and watch in bemusement as their public sector brethren suck up more and more cash – mostly to do things they don’t want to happen – where these people start voting Tory.

These are the people who were most damaging by the smoking ban, who are irritated by the endless nannying lectures on drinking, eating and, seemingly, everything else they enjoy. These are the people who are roundly cynical about global warming, who want to use cheap flights to warm places once or twice a year. These are the people who’ve seen labour rob their pensions, let them down on education and want to tax them to the hilt for the horrible crime of using their cars.

And let me close by saying this: if Anthony Wells analysis is right then David Cameron has his strategy wrong. Sucking up to middle-class Lib Dem voting public sector professional and labour-voting social workers by coming across all green simply isn’t delivering – in fact, if we carry on like this, we’ll just alienate those hard-working people who hate labour more than they love the Tories.

...

Wednesday, 6 January 2010

Soft outcomes need hard measures to be acceptable in policy-making

***

Julian Dobson writes Living with Rats – you should all read it. Not only is it well-written, insightful and thoughtful but he talks about things that matter to real people outside the bureaucratic circle – why some places are crap, why regeneration is about people rather than buildings and why too often local initiative is stifled by the demands of national government, big business or great institutions. He’s also a Hammer.

However, sometimes Julian lets his writerliness get ahead of things and this post, “Why is it so hard to be soft?”, is one example. What follows is a gentle fisk – responding to a series of questions posed by Julian. At the heart of this is the common fallacy that economics is about money (it isn’t) and that opinion or feeling is impossible to quantify (let me introduce the Opinion Poll). Julian’s words are in italics:

It's hard to measure the quality of a person's life. But you'd have to be a bit soft to think you could do it entirely by calculating their income.

Well yes of course which is why we don’t measure quality of life using income measures – we use other objective measures: what we consume, our health, our conditions of living, our ability to act freely. All of these are strong quantitative measures to which can be added the tremendous contribution of market research towards the quantitative measurement of opinion.

It's hard to assess the success of a policy against a range of desirables, such as economic output, sustainability and equality. But you'd have to be a bit soft to think the one that's easiest to measure numerically is by definition a good proxy for all the others.

No it’s not – so long as we set clear quantifiable outcomes (and such exist for economic output, sustainability and equality) then measurement is merely a matter of collecting and assessing the necessary data. If a policy does not have, say, equality objectives then to measure it against such “objectives” is mistaken and bad research – a classic flaw in policy evaluation is that the scope of the evaluation is set in hindsight without consideration of the original intentions behind the policy-making.

It's hard to measure how worthwhile and rewarding a person's job is, and harder still to measure it across a workforce. But you'd have to be a bit soft to think that the net number of jobs was more important than the sense of self-worth, motivation and aspiration people feel in doing them.

It seems obvious that, for the quarter of the working age population without a job, the “net number” (not sure what it’s netted from) of jobs is of crucial importance. And the knowledge that, if they had a job, it would be worthwhile and rewarding ain’t much comfort!

It's hard to calculate the value of a cultural asset like a theatre or art gallery or public artwork or live music venue. But you'd have to be a bit soft to think you could do it just by bums on seats or spending on merchandise and tickets.

There are real measures of cultural value beyond ticket sales, market price or merchandise. Crucially, approaches seek to capture either the opportunity cost (life without the cultural asset) or to price culture. Simply saying “oo isn’t it lovely” doesn’t wash!

It's hard to calculate how people feel about where they live and how involved they are in their communities. But you'd have to be a bit soft to imagine the price of houses or the proportion of people voting will tell you the whole story

First, house prices are a nice proxy for what people generally think of a place – that thinking may not reflect everything but it does reveal where people want to live! We can measure involvement (and be “shocked” at how low it is), we can use self-referenced definitions of community and we can use good old opinion research to ascertain what they think about where they live.

...

The point of all this isn’t to dismiss qualitative “research” – if you want to frame a question, get an instant response to an idea, provide some context to research or guide our tactical decision-making. But qualitative research must not lull us into rejecting scientific method – the testing of hypotheses with repeatable experiments with results that are quantitatively comparable.

...

Sunday, 4 October 2009

Opinion polls and the science of the dead cat bounce

There appear to be different opinions about the veracity or otherwise of claims that deceased felines rebound when dropped from a great height. The evidence of large amounts of force on animals suggests more squish than bounce – at least judging from the too frequent roadside evidence. It seems to me however that the propensity for bounce from our dead moggy depends on these factors:

A. Condition of the dead cat
B. Height from which the dead cat falls
C. Nature of the surface below the falling pussy


Using a recent suggested “dead cat bounce” from UK politics let’s examine whether the bounce is real or an illusion. The example is a daily tracking opinion poll on 30th September 2009 (from YouGov) that showed the Conservative lead over Labour down to just 7 percentage points. Coming during Labour’s annual gathering this poll resulted in some excitable comment from Labour supporters and the suggestion (from some perhaps more rightwardly inclined) that even dead cats bounce when dropped from a great height!

Condition of the dead cat. In this case the dead cat is the Labour Party. To be fair the cat’s condition could be quite a lot worse (indeed some are insisting that there are signs of life in the old mog yet) and I doubt whether rigor mortis has set in. So: a) Definitely dead; b) Died recently but no longer warm

Height from which the dead cat has fallen. The highest point for Labour’s opinion poll rating since 2005 was 44% in a YouGov Poll for Channel 4 in September 2007. The poll reported above with a 7 point lead put Labour on 30% and the lowest rating they have received (ignoring the 19% achieved in the real European election) is 23% in a ComRes poll for the Independent only three days earlier on 27th September 2009. A long way down!

Nature of the receiving surface. The fall is I surmise onto the pliant surface of the media as a proxy for the rather rougher and tougher surface of public opinion in general. It seems to me a little like those weird spongy surfaces we find under swings and roundabouts these days. As soon as one lot are down the media switches to talking down the other lot in a frantic and often purile attempt at balance. These surfaces are designed for kids to bounce so we have to conclude that our dead cat will bounce too!

So to conclude:

1. The Labour Party is a cold dead cat but not yet stiff
2. The Party fell a long way – 48% of the political slippery pole’s height
3. The spongy surface of the media (plus wall-to-wall coverage) provided bounce


Dead cats do bounce (ceteris paribus) – and recent polls bear this out as Labour’s poll rating falls back again!