Showing posts with label private ownership. Show all posts
Showing posts with label private ownership. Show all posts

Monday, 6 June 2011

'Vanity of vanities, all is vanity, says the preacher..."


This time though the vain preacher is an atheist:


Gifted students will be able to apply to the New College of the Humanities in central London to take degrees in a range of subjects such as law, economics and philosophy. The college – which will open next year – will become only the second fully private university to be established in Britain after Buckingham. Prof AC Grayling, the philosopher and famed atheist, will be the college's first Master. 

The announcement has brought a torrent of negative comment from the world of academia and in the pages of their house journal, The Guardian:

What would prevent most of us from doing so is the nausea which wells to the throat at the thought of this disgustingly elitist outfit. British universities, plundered of resources by the bankers and financiers they educated, are not best served by a bunch of prima donnas jumping ship and creaming off the bright and loaded.
 
Now part of me hopes - even expects - the project, with its self-importance, inflated fees and expensive faculty to fail but not because it is a private initiative.  Indeed, the option of becoming private should be a consideration for our elite universities - rather than passing pointless motions of no confidence in government ministers, academics at Oxford and Cambridge would be better served forcing that minister's hand by threatening to go private, to break away from the state's clammy, controlling hand.

No, what is wrong with this project is, as one observer points out, its vanity:

This is not a College but a branding exercise: the use of big academic names to gloss straightforward London University degrees and charge the courses out at five times the cost using the same facilities.

Almost all the contentions made on the College’s website are misconceived, or do not seem to be substantiated. All this is clear with the application of the critical thinking and an evidence-based approach which the humanities should actually promote and celebrate.

This College is not any academic breakthrough. This College does nothing real to help the humanities in this country.

It is instead AC Grayling’s Folly.

Maybe the college has a substantive, worked through business plan that will show how an institution can charge twice what Britain's only other private university charges. However, I suspect that they've merely added up the cost of Professor Grayling's expensive friends, divided it by the number of students these friends will deign to tutor and arrived at the figure of £18,000.

My personal view is that Britain needs private universities - I would cheer if most of the Russell Group of "elite" universities escaped from the State's clutches and set their sights on competing with the top American academic institutions. But Grayling's little scheme seems to be an indulgent, formless vanity project. And that's why it will fail.

....

Thursday, 24 March 2011

Public health and private choice - thoughts on a consultation

This afternoon I attended a Public Health Consultation event organised (because I insisted) to allow Bradford councillors to have some input into the PCT/Council response to the Public Health White Paper. Obviously our input was constrained by time but we managed to comment at length on:

Domains and Indicators from Healthy Lives, Healthy People: Transparency in Outcomes: Proposals for a Public Health Outcomes Framework

And:

Commissioning and funding from Healthy Lives Healthy People: Consultation on the funding and commissioning routes for public health

In this discussion we looked at the different “measures” that might be applied to the assessment of public health effectiveness and hence the likelihood of Bradford Council receiving the “Health Premium” promised to Councils meeting targets. In listening to this – and looking at the targets – it struck me that there is an interesting and important discussion to be had as to what we actually mean by the term “public health”.

What seems clear to me is that the domain of public health – our concern to do something about external and environmental factors contributing to disease and ill-health – has expanded to encompass things that are not external to individual choice. Hence the ‘new’ definition from the Faculty of Public Health:

“The science and art of promoting and protecting health and well-being, preventing ill health and prolonging life through the organised efforts of society.”

Public health is no longer concerned with externalities – with sanitation, with poor housing, with air pollution, with clean water – but with lifestyle choices deemed by “society” to be wrong. And the justification for this action is all couched in generic health outcomes, chiefly in “life expectancy” and “healthy life expectancy”.  Because, for example, reducing smoking is seen as improving overall “life expectancy” it becomes justified even though such interventions are not in areas of ‘public goods’.

Underlying this argument is the nature of the deal between the individual and the state – whether that deal in a collective or individual arrangement, between the ‘civic’ and the ‘personal’. And, most commonly, the argument is couched in terms of selfishness – my drinking, smoking or fatness means a greater burden on the NHS and less resource available to treat the illnesses of good people who eschew such a decadent lifestyle.

If however – as I believe is the case – my relationship with the state is a personal one, then this argument is false. I pay taxes, duties and other imposts in return for the state’s protection. And that protection applies to me personally not to me as part of a collective. My lifestyle choices – smoking, drinking, eating burgers, sky-diving, potholing, and so forth – are not a matter of public concern. Therefore public health cannot – as its proponents now argue – extend to controlling lifestyle choices but must be limited to public goods and to the impact of public services on health.

Nevertheless, the consultation paper on “proposed indicators” contains nine targets directly linked to levels of smoking, drinking or eating yet just two relating directly to housing. Yet housing conditions – damp, drafts, poor heating – are very significant factors in ill-health, arguably more significant that smoking, drinking or obesity. Add to this the incidence of ill-health linked to long-term unemployment and poverty and it is clear to me that the directing of around 60% of public health budgets to booze, fags and burgers is wholly misplaced – even if we accept the argument that there is a need to develop responses to these “problems”.

In the end, the experts – those nannying fussbuckets of the Faculty of Public Health – will win the day and the funding will go to continue the current strategy. And this is despite all the evidence that this strategy is failing to deal with the problem it intends to deal with (too much drinking, smoking and burger-eating). At the meeting I pointed out that reports of liver disease had risen during a time when the consumption of alcohol was falling – the answer to this conundrum is that the problem drinkers are drinking more ergo more liver disease!  I’m not sure that I believe this – the problem may relate more to the increase in drinking during the 1980s and the lag in presentation for liver conditions.

While I enjoyed the meeting and made a substantial and, hopefully, substantive contribution, I expect that we will end up with a centrally directed, nannying (or should I say nudging) approach focused – to the exclusion of almost everything else – on the poor lifestyle choices that some people make. And it won’t work – the single mum on the sixth floor of a council block will still want cheap stimuli, the little cheers and buzzes that get her through an otherwise crap life. Which means she’ll carry on smoking, drinking, enjoying sex, eating crisps or chocolate and watching telly – those things are her pleasures and telling her it’s bad for her won’t change a thing.

 If you want to change her outlook – or the outlook of a million or so other folk – you have to change economic prospects, improve the housing and clean up the locality. And all the public health fussbucketry won’t achieve any of that, will it?

....

Tuesday, 30 March 2010

Markets, ownership and the politics of place

I have spent the past couple of days at a Symposium on Place-making and Culture - two days that have been educational and eye-opening. And I say this both positively and negatively.

On the positive side there is a real recognition that places aren't manufactured - indeed that attempts to manufacture great places are often a failure. Linked to this is the concern that our planning system - a rigidly moderated collection of rules, regulations and guidance notes - acts to stifle the creativity and originality of community efforts to create place. Yet sadly, nobody present questioned either the need for a rule-bound planning system or suggested that the term "place-making intervention" is profoundly undemocratic.

Instead we had a species of naive Marxism - the "triple challenge of peak oil, climate change and financial collapse" explained as indicative of the "crisis of late capitalism". This latter is a term I hadn't heard expressed seriously since the early 1980s - perhaps indicating how the debate about economic recovery will play out. Academics from the social sciences and arts seem charmed by the pseudo-economics of the New Economics Foundation and its associated brand of cuddly Marxism. And central to this world view is the search for an "alternative definition of value" - I have heard in the past two days people advocate land nationalisation and the proposal for a 'social valuation of land'.

Now I'm happy that most of this will remain safely contained - mostly harmlessly - within social science departments of newer universities and in the wackier fringes of arts practice. But I am a little worried that no-one is prepared to make the case for private ownership and the free market. Presenters and contributors all started from the view point that there is a "paradigm shift" away from free markets (a statement I find almost entirely without meaning yet glibly accepted by these modern day pseudo-Marxists).

Great places are great places because of the accumulated actions of individuals who 'intervene' in that place - by being traders or customer of traders, by commissioning architects and designers, by being those so commissioned, by renting an office there, by walking round admiring the buzz, by painting a wall, by busking on the corner...by a myriad of private actions taken without reference to public authorities and often, in truth, performed in the teeth of opposition by those public authorities that banter on so smugly about place-making.

And at the heart of all this is ownership - private ownership. People who own something tend to care for it, will police the actions of those who make use of it and seek most of the time to maintain and improve that something. Public space - by not being owned - is only cared for through the medium of those public authorities who want to control and direct our lives and activities. The authorities who don't like buskers, peddlers and street traders. The authorities who ban signs, who seek rents and taxes from private actors and who wish to stigmatise pleasure and enjoyment.

So step one in "making" great places is for governments and planners to shove out of the way. Step two is to promote the private ownership of space. And step three is to allow the market to do what it does best - create new activities, attract customers, create excitement and generate the value that makes for a great place.

...