Showing posts with label productivity. Show all posts
Showing posts with label productivity. Show all posts

Tuesday, 23 July 2019

On the productivity problem - are we measuring the right things?



From Goldman Sachs via Reason:
Goldman Sachs's economic research team has found that a lot of the innovation Silicon Valley generates isn't captured by standard measurements of GDP. For example, while email, direct messaging, and Google Maps clearly make all kinds of work easier or more efficient, they're free, so GDP doesn't include the value consumers gain from using them. It's telling that a recent MIT study found that the median person would be willing to pay more than $40 a month for Facebook. Just because users don't pay for a service doesn't mean they don't value it.
Every time I see an article on the dilemma of productivity (despite technological advance productivity flatlines) I think of this issue. After all back in 2008 almost nobody had a smartphone yet now they are ubiquitous and pretty cheap - I got a temporary one for £20 when my phone smashed. Yet little of this obvious betterment makes its way through into productivity measures.

Now since I'm not an economist I always tread carefully when dipping my toe in the waters of this sort of subject. It does seem, however, that there's been a shift in betterment from advancing productivity in the work place to a much more interesting improvement in consumer's lives. We always joke - "so much for austerity" - as we pass another dog walker's van parked up on the edge of the moor. A decade or so ago such businesses as dog walkers simply didn't exist but now there's sufficient money out there for people to afford to pay someone else to walk the dog.

This is just one example to which could be added a loads of others from specialist dessert cafes through to smartphone app based products like Airbnb, Uber and assorted takeaway delivery services. There's a craft beer explosion accompanied by hundreds of micro-pubs to go with the hundreds of micro-breweries and more places to eat and drink than we ever imagined. For not a lot of money people access a wealth of live sport, film, TV, games and other entertainment. And even if you're not prepared to pay an extra sub there's the joys of YouTube and the plethora of podcasts and ad-enabled music streams.

The point here is that consumers are seeing the benefits of technology ahead of businesses. The disruptive technologies - taxicabs, hotel rooms, food service - are not advances that, in the main, lead to productivity gains in business. This isn't to say that, in services such as law and accountancy, there aren't advances to be made or that the advent of new transport technologies won't see productivity gains as the need for drivers diminishes. But not only is business slow to change but also the outlook of government is to protect the existing infrastructure whether it's a legacy transport system like heavy rail or a professional protection that means, for example, only a human lawyer can do something.

Frontier Economics looked at the effect of ebay in the UK, France and Germany and found:
...eBay helps consumers save around 24 percent of what they would otherwise spend in France, Germany, and the United Kingdom. That translates to 1.1 billion Euros in savings per year.
None - or precious little - of this gain is translated into traditional measures of productivity and GDP. The critical change is that huge consumer benefits are delivered by Google, Facebook and other free-to-air platforms but while we calculate the contribution of these firms' ad revenue we ignore the value of the benefits realised by the mass of consumers using the free services.

We forget that these services - Twitter, Facebook, eBay, Uber, Airbnb, Spotify - didn't exist or were babies back in 2007 yet now are some of the most significant, almost dominant, consumer services to the point where politicians now want to clobber consumers by regulating or controlling these businesses. It there has been productivity gain - let's call it betterment - then it has been in the lives of consumers not the efficiency of businesses.

.....

Wednesday, 10 February 2016

In which we are reminded that the NHS management don't understand economics

****

It starts with this:

‘Collectively and cumulatively [these actions] and others like them will help shift power to patients and citizens, strengthen communities, improve health and wellbeing, and – as a by-product – help moderate rising demands on the NHS’

This is the rather ghastly sounding 'Health as a Social Movement' line in the NHS's vain attempts to pretend that preventative medicine will 'moderate rising demands'. What is most striking here is that, yet again, the basic economics of all this are overlooked (although given they've appointed the risible joke of a think tank, New Economics Foundation, it's pretty clear they're not remotely interested in actual real economics).

Unless the project is about improving productivity through these community-focused actions then the only impact - assuming they do improve health and wellbeing - will be to increase the long-term demands (and hence costs) on the NHS.

The report ...projected that people with Type 2 diabetes who participated in a disease management program to prevent serious complications would cost the federal government slightly more money over 25 years than they would have without any intervention.

If you stop and think about this for a second, the reason for a healthy community being more expensive is pretty obvious - most of the costs in the health system (and the care system too) are directed towards older people so if more people live to a ripe old age there are more of those 'end of life' costs.

To use a big example, we've seen a massive decline in the numbers of and in survival rates from heart attacks - since 2002 the mortality rate has more than halved. In simple terms this means there are double the number of long-term heart 'patients' compared to the old days when they all died of a heart attack. This absolutely brilliant and a credit to doctors, pharmacists and the health benefits of a bigger, richer economy. But it's costing the NHS a fortune.

And it's not just heart attacks but every sort of disease, from childhood infectious diseases through to cancers, that has seen declining mortality rates. And this means it's pretty normal to live into your 80s, not unusual to make it to 90 and increasingly common for folk to make it to 100. So when we act - quite rightly - to prevent disease and reduce mortality rates the result is more and more old people and more and more demand for the NHS services that are under so much strain.

The challenge for healthcare is to improve productivity - to reduce unit costs for operations, for providing care, for dispensing medicines, for all the vast array of stuff health care does. And spending money on "health as a social movement" only does this if it means that the allocation of NHS resources to these communities is thereby reduced. So long as we focus on simple prevention as a demand management tool, we will find no benefit in higher productivity and a pile more demand-led costs for the system.

This is, of course, what you get if you believe that NESTA, the RSA and New Economics Foundation are the sorts of organisations that are able to guide the NHS towards greater efficiency and higher productivity. A load of left-wing cant and absolutely no moderation of rising demand.

....