Showing posts with label waste management. Show all posts
Showing posts with label waste management. Show all posts

Tuesday, 7 August 2018

Mushrooms can help resolve our waste disposal problems. Why are we ignoring them?


So I'm sat in an LGA EEHT Board meeting (don't ask) and the matter under discussion is waste management. You know about this stuff as it has been all over the telly - bans on straws, the Great Pacific Garbage Patch, those pesky Chinese saying they won't take our rubbish any more, and hand-wringing greens tutting about our sinful consumer lifestyles. We're listening to a report about technology, waste streams and something called the "circular economy". I have to tell you it isn't gripping but that, since we're all councillors, the matter of collecting, recycling and disposing of the rubbish we all produce is a core part of what we do - local councils empty the bins.

Funny thing is that all I could think of was mushrooms. And I regret not raising the subject at the meeting since, as you all should know, fungi contain the salvation for our planet including dealing with pollution:
Certain species, such as the oyster mushroom, produce enzymes that digest the hydrocarbons in petroleum. Some can absorb heavy metals like mercury and even digest polyurethane plastics. Scientists are also experimenting to see if certain types of fungi might be able to absorb radiation after nuclear disasters.
Yet in all the meetings, the reports, the debates on waste the matter of mushrooms never arises. I wonder why?
...cultivating the right type of mushroom on soiled nappies can break down 90% of the material they are made of within two months. Within four, they are degraded completely. What is more, she says, despite their unsavoury diet the fungi in question, Pleurotus ostreatus (better known as oyster mushrooms), are safe to eat. To prove the point she has, indeed, eaten them.
Fungi Mutarium is a prototype that grows edible fungal biomass, mainly the mycelium, as a novel food product. Fungi is cultivated on specifically designed agar shapes that the designers called "FU". Agar is a seaweed based gelatin substitute and acts, mixed with starch and sugar, as a nutrient base for the fungi. The "FUs" are filled with plastics. The fungi is then inserted, it digests the plastic and overgrows the whole substrate. The shape of the "FU" is designed so that it holds the plastic and to offer the fungi a lot of surface to grow on.
Several organisms demonstrated the ability to efficiently degrade PUR (synthetic polymer polyester polyurethane) in both solid and liquid suspensions. Particularly robust activity was observed among several isolates in the genus Pestalotiopsis, although it was not a universal feature of this genus. Two Pestalotiopsis microspora isolates were uniquely able to grow on PUR as the sole carbon source under both aerobic and anaerobic conditions.
By feeding agricultural waste to Mycelium (the webs of thread-like mushroom roots) under correct conditions, the waste is turned into a material that can be moulded into any shape, having similar properties to Styrofoam – a polymer-based material made from Polystyrene.
Mushrooms can be used to clean up oil spills, accelerate landfill decomposition, as a structural base for lightweight panels, and as a means to extract rare minerals from trash. Yet there seems to be little or no significant research into the commercialisation of these systems. I may be that they don't scale up but I suspect that waste managers - including councils - don't want to be the first to say "we're going to grow oyster mushrooms on our landfill" because they're worried everyone would point and laugh.

....

Sunday, 7 October 2012

NEF talking rubbish about rubbish...


View from the top of the restored Manywells landfill, Cullingworth
A consultant to the New Economics Foundation writes about Biffa's problems. And manages to entirely miss the point - or demonstrate having done any research into the company.

Biffa, the waste disposal company that carries out much local authority work, is profitable, admired by the unions that represent much of its 6,000-strong workforce, praised by local authorities like south Oxfordshire district council as innovative and efficient, and responsible over the years for developing a lot of the improvements that have spruced up UK rubbish collection and recycling.

Lets get some things clear about Biffa. For sure it does a lot of local authority work - outsourced contracts of one sort or another up and down the land. But this isn't where it has made its money - it makes that from filling up holes in the ground with rubbish not from collecting said rubbish from your doorstep. And while I applaud left-wing (so-called) economists when they enthuse about outsourcing, they really should check the facts first.

The cause of the problem? Here's a clue from a Telegraph report:

Biffa is more exposed to industrial waste, which makes up 80pc of its business, than municipal waste. The shift away from landfill and towards recycling has compounded its problems.

Trading has been made more difficult, too, thanks to a Government tax hike on companies still reliant on landfill, and the trend for big companies, such as Tesco, to deal with their own waste.

Last week HMRC closed a Landfill Tax loophole, which is expected to add extra strain on the company. 

Far from the company's problems being a consequence of evil capitalists, they are largely down to the ongoing landfill tax escalator - a rising charge on landfill intended to shift disposal away from holes in the ground and promote recycling. I'm sure NEF approves!

The NEF consultant wants "us" (I guess she means the government using taxpayers' money) to protect Biffa from these awful capitalists. We should have a plan (quite what it is the writer is unclear about). And we should learn:

The Biffa case study shouldn't be wasted. It is an object lesson in how we have let the market run our real economy – rather than, as it should be, the other way round.

Read this sentence a few times. It is a straightforward argument for "us" (the state, I guess) organising the "market". It is utter rubbish - Biffa's problems are a consequence of bad management (borrowing too much against future earnings) and government policy (making it uneconomic to stick rubbish in holes rather than burning it or recycling it). Nothing at all to do with "the market". Nothing.

....



Wednesday, 15 December 2010

A good day in Denholme

****

Today, Bradford Council refused permission for the development of a landfill site at Buck Park Quarry near Denholme. In the greater scheme of things a rather minor decision but, for the village concerned, a day for smiles all round. For several reasons.

Firstly, landfill is dirty, messy and mostly unnecessary. The UK's preference for sticking rotting rubbish into holes in the ground rather than using more responsible (and economic) approaches such as waste to energy remains a mystery. I know that the greenies like Friends of the Earth seem to think that incineration is a greater sin than allowing the rubbish to rot slowly into the ground but, in truth it is the most environmentally damaging method of disposal.

Secondly, Denholme villagers campaigned long and hard against the proposals. A previous application was refused by Councillors (against the wishes of planning officers) and only granted permission at an appeal where - shamefully - Bradford Council refused to submit evidence on the specious grounds that they might lose and be awarded costs. To say this spat in the face of local people and the Councillors who voted to refuse permission is an understatement. For technical reasons the development was stopped as local people - again without Council support - took the developer to the High Court where they won. With the result being that the planning permission lapsed (and the Council then won a further High Court case brought by the developer).

Thirdly, the outcome today vindicates the only pledge I made to the electorate four years ago - that I would vote against any proposal or policy that would make landfill more likely even if that proposal was from my party. I did this - voting against the Council's waste management strategy in full council because my group had accepted a Liberal Democrat amendment ruling out waste to energy as a disposal option.

Denholme isn't free from the threat of landfill just yet - I fully expect the developer to appeal. But this time - after fifteen years of equivocation - the Council is on the side of local people. Fighting the appeal won't be down to local fundraising, the odd bit of pro bono work from lawyers and planners and the research efforts of residents. I have every hope that we will win the appeal and that, at last, we will see Denholme free from having the District's rotting rubbish dumped in this convenient hole in the ground.

....

Tuesday, 7 July 2009

Manywells tip and the failings of environmental policies - why the Greens are wrong.

Back in the early 1990s planning permission was granted for a landfill site to be constructed in the disused Manywells Quarry on the hill above Cullingworth. Over the subsequent 9 years or so much of Bradford's household waste - the stuff you and I put in the bin every week - was dumped in the site. Now think for a few moments about what you throw away - the empty bleach bottles, the batteries, used medicines, cosmetics containers and unwanted food. Even the most assiduous of recyclers throws some of this away and the result is a poisonous mess of highly contaminated waste as dangerous in many ways as the 'hazardous' waste some campaigners get so bothered about.

Landfill sites for controlled waste (such as the stuff you throw away) are essentially a large plastic bag stuck in a hole in the ground - a sophisticated plastic bag to be sure - but still a pretty fair description. As the stuff placed in this bag rots it generates gas - methane, carbon dioxide, carbon monoxide and sulphur compounds in various mixes - and leachate (about which the less said the better - you really don't want to know what's in it). As you can see this isn't a very environmentally sustainable way to deal with waste - indeed landfill is considered the least sustainable means of dealing with our rubbish. As a result Government's across Europe have agreed to reduce the amount of waste going to landfill by 50% by 2012 (a target we'll almost certainly miss).

Cullingworth folk know about landfill - before Manywells they put up with the even larger and more contaminating Sugden End tip (which took over £5 million to remediate) - which explains why the recycling point in the village is one of the District's best used! And I have spent much of my time as a Councillor trying - often in vain - to get the Council to improve its waste strategy and to stop planner approving more of these hideous contaminating places.

So what's this got to do with the 'Greens'? Surely they agree with all this stuff about reducing waste? Well yes and no is the answer - the 'Greens' call for the reduction of waste to landfill, get all agitated about supermarket packaging, plastic bags and nappies but fail to answer the obvious question - what is the alternative? When asked this simple question they get all hypothetical and talk about 'zero waste strategies' as an aspiration rather than answering the question - what are going to do with all the rubbish we're generating NOW?

So just like the most sensible medium term approach to reducing carbon emissions is nuclear energy - which the 'Greens' (proving once again their anti-science credentials) don't like - the sensible medium term solution to the waste issue is to carry on the effective strategy of reduction, reuse and recycling and combine it with energy-from-waste via incineration or other heat treatment. The alternative is that we will go on using landfills - nasty, smelly, contaminating, greenhouse gas generating piles of rotting rubbish. The 'Greens' are wrong to oppose incineration because of their absolutist obsession with the (quite appealling but rather utopian) idea of 'zero waste'.