Showing posts with label innovation strategies. Show all posts
Showing posts with label innovation strategies. Show all posts

Tuesday, 30 October 2012

Science and growth. It really isn't as simple as all that...

****

Science is wonderful. I'll sign up to government investing in basic science every day. But I don't think it's a growth panacea. Lots of people do though:

The private sector can’t do it alone. We rely on companies to translate scientific discoveries into products. But federal investment in research and development, especially basic research, is critical to their success.

Now the author of those words is a physics professor and former scientific advisor to President Clinton so we might say he has an interest. But his view is widely held - investment in science, technology and maths by governments is a surefire route to growth. The problem is that there's precious little link (at least in the medium term) between investment in basic science and economic growth.





You see folks. Spending money on scientific research in universities doesn't cut the mustard as a growth strategy. A while ago in a different circumstance I wrote this:



We need, therefore, to examine what other (ideally measurable) inputs might improve our assessment of innovation.  Some authors identify ‘learning-by-doing’ as a factor in innovation (Iyigun 2006) while others argue for exogenous factors such as the size of the (innovating) population (Jones 1995).  This latter measure suggests that a better proxy for innovation activity might be the number of ‘knowledge workers’.  Such an approach would capture R&D workers and other workers involved in innovative activities. 

It seemed to me then that government is better placed investing in creating scientists, engineers and mathematicians rather than spending money on basic research in those subjects. At least if they want to generate growth. And for those regions that want to shift their economies they need to get lots of these people to live and work there. That means they aren't stuck with the one employer of those skills or forced to flit from one end of the country to the other so change jobs. And more importantly there will be plenty of people to partner with in developing and actioning innovative ideas.

This was a central failing of the UK's Regional Development Agencies (RDAs). All of them had innovation strategies but all of these strategies were, in effect, captured by higher education. Rather than focusing on innovation in business the RDAs spent their cash instead on funding research institutes and university-led strategies sited too close to their research.


There is evidence to suggest that university-led innovation strategies focusing on collaboration and the spinning off of businesses from HEIs leads to a misplaced focus on scientific research rather than business growth (Jones 1995, Frenz & Oughton 2005).  Perhaps the most effective way to generate effective innovation at the level of the firm (where it has a direct impact on economic performance) is to reduce the barriers to innovation.  The biggest of these barriers is cost and econometric models suggest that reducing innovation costs is more effective that investing in R&D or building innovation networks and systems (Martin 1999).  

In the long-term scientific research does help drive the technological advances that lead to economic growth. The problem is that, in the short- to medium-term, it's very difficult to spot the beneficial effects of such research especially when compared to the promotion of in-firm innovation.

References (yay, I don't do this often!):



Frenz M. & Oughton C. (2005), ‘Innovation in the UK regions and devolved administrations: a review of the literature’ presentation of report for DTI and ODPM, London, DTI

Iyigun M. (2006), ‘Clusters of invention, life cycle of technologies and endogenous growth’ in Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control, Vol. 30 pp687-719, New York, Elsevier

Jones C I, (1995), ‘R&D-based models of economic growth’ in Journal of Political Economy, Vol. 103 No. 4 pp759-783, University of Chicago

Martin P. (1999), ‘Public policies, regional inequalities and growth’ in Journal of Public Economics Vol. 73 pp 85-105, New York, Elsevier



....

Thursday, 27 September 2012

A brief thought about innovation strategies and growth...

****

The innovation strategy - or innovation-led growth -  isn't usually about "innovation" but is about government investment in science and in manufacturing industry. Stuff like:

A £200m fund for early-stage ventures; freedom to raise money for the Green Investment Bank, and a new business bank to lend to growth sectors including advanced manufacture and life sciences.

..and

Invest the proceeds of the forthcoming 4G spectrum auction - estimated at £4bn - in science, technology and innovation.

Plus...

Higher education funds for radical inventions around knowledge creation - putting design thinking at the heart of the new Catapult centres.

All good stuff and "targeted" at the things that made regions "competitive" - at innovation. Or so we're told. The truth is that innovation - or a great deal of it - isn't about science but about boring things like systems and distribution. Amazon's success is as much built on getting super swift logistics as it is about whizzo techie wonderments. But it's the latter that suck up the innovation funding from governments.

The problem is that, while innovation is awfully important at the firm level, at the macro level there's not much evidence that R&D spending impacts on growth:

And here lies our problem. We know that innovation generates growth (by reducing costs, by creating new products and so forth) but we can't capture that growth by looking at the sort of investments that typify government innovation strategies. Indeed, if a firm only innovates because of grant-funding (or 'soft loans' which amount to the same hill of beans) then we have to question whether the innovation is real or merely staged to secure the funding.

It seems to me - and there is some evidence to support this - that the real benefits lie in:

  • Concentrations of private sector knowledge workers (think Thames Valley)
  • Low (or no) taxes on capital gains
  • A focus on service/process innovation (services are 80% of our economy after all)
  • Active incentives (such as reduced taxes) for business innovation
  • Similar incentives for individual investors in innovation (tax reliefs or lower personal taxes)

What is clear however is that schemes predicated on the activities of universities - clutching another batch of government funding to their chests - do not deliver innovation and do not benefit growth.

....