Showing posts with label local plans. Show all posts
Showing posts with label local plans. Show all posts

Sunday, 15 September 2019

Cottingley - a planning fairy tale




A few days ago a local landowner and developer announced plans to build 155 homes on land near the village of Cottingley (yes folks the place where the fairies live). The site in question is in the 'green belt' although the owners have, I suspect, a reasonable chance under Bradford's local plan of seeing it allocated for housing. I'm also sure that the development will be fought tooth and nail by neighbouring residents.

The applicant knows that he has to make the case that there is an overwhelming need for the the homes such that the Council can set aside the current 'green belt' designation. They have this to say:
“We are aware of a very acute shortage of local housing and we are proposing to submit a planning application that not only delivers market and affordable housing to meet a local need but also propose very extensive areas of public greenspace to be enjoyed by all local residents. We are proud of our local business development achievements and have held this land for a considerable number of years."
We are then reminded that the Council has failed year after year to get anywhere close to the target set for new homes (it was over 800 short for 2017-18) and that there is a real shortage of housing as witnessed by the rise in house prices. I'll leave this to play out (I'm no longer Cottingley's local councillor) but my best guess is that, despite the lack of a five-year land supply, the development will be refused on 'green belt' grounds.

Instead I'd like to talk about Bradford's local plan and, more broadly, about the local plan process in general. Responding to the proposed development the Council says this:
“The proposed core strategy does not allocate any housing sites in Cottingley, however, the review is in its early stages and will be subject to consultation and examination. It could be several years before it is formally adopted.”
The first part might mislead - the purpose of the core strategy is to establish what housing is needed and where. It may not allocate housing sites but it does identify the amount of housing needed in places like Cottingley. Bradford Council formally adopted a core strategy in July 2017 and this tells us that Cottingley needs 395 new homes during the plan period. Given the village is entirely surrounded by 'green belt' the only place for this housing to go is on that 'green belt'. So the landowner has a point.

But Bradford Council, a matter of months after approving a core strategy and before it had got round to deciding precisely where it wanted the new housing (and other stuff) to go, has decided to review its core strategy. Ostensibly this review responds to changes in national planning policies such as a standard method to the calculation of housing need and adjustments to the definition of affordable housing. The Council also spotted - I made a lengthy representation at examination on this so it wasn't a surprise - that a lot of housing sites in the inner city are not viable and is saying now that "deliverability and viability" are central to plan-making.

So, while Bradford Council does have an adopted core strategy it doesn't have a completed local plan and is reviewing that core strategy. The Council say that formal adoption isn't expected until "early 2022" and this assumes the process runs smoothly, that there aren't further tweaks needed following national policy debates and that the politicians allow time. And only when this process is complete can the Council begin to look at actual allocations. It could be 2025 before the Council has a complete, examined and adopted local plan. The process of producing the local plan started in 2008 - seventeen years filled with consultancy reports, housing assessments, calls for sites and regulatory appraisal documents, examinations and political bun fights.

Am I alone in thinking this is no way to run a planning system and that it's no surprise to see landowners, house-builders and developers jumping the gun to push forward sites they want to develop - sites Bradford needs to meet housing requirements. And Bradford is not alone - by 2017 over 40% of English planning authorities had not adopted a plan and many began their process before Bradford. And, since this year's local elections, council after council is trying to pull their local plan (examples include Vale of White Horse, Woking, Guildford, Braintree and Uttlesford) because the new political leadership got elected off the back of opposing housing development. The system is a joke.

If a sensible government wants to improve housing delivery, save local councils money and have a planning system that is accessible then the best piece of advice I can give them is to scrap the local plan process. It is unwieldy, over-complicated and inefficient. It's reliance on a comprehensive evidence base is ludicrous because the time taken to gather the evidence and have it examined makes that evidence, in a dynamic environment, out-of-date. The result is Councils, Bradford is a good example, that do and redo strategic housing market assessments and land availability assessments in a vain endeavour to get an up-to-date plan. Great news for consultants but not for an efficient planning system.

We need either a much simpler and more broad brush system or else to deal with applications on a case-by-case basis using rules on rolling land supply (five years worth of housing sites, for example) alongside wider protections (landscape, heritage, ecology, etc.) to make decisions rather than wait for an allocations plan. Alongside sensible changes to national policies around 'green belts' such as excluding previously-developed land from 'green belt' constraint this could result in a planning system more able to meet need that the elaborate and expensive plan-led approach we use today.

....

Monday, 22 July 2019

Some thoughts on reforming planning to support housing need


With the Mayor of London joining other 'progressive' mayors in places like New York, Berlin and Auckland by opting for rent controls over building houses, we are reminded that every politician is prepared to ignore economic reality in the search for short-term electoral benefit. Since nearly every serious economist says that rent controls are a bad idea, you have to wonder why they are so popular?

The problem - whether in London or San Francisco - is that politics removes the solution to rising housing costs that actually does make economic sense. Rent controls are the inevitable consequence of housing policies directed by the political power of NIMBYs. Here's housing economist Professor Paul Cheshire being interviewed by Ahir Hites, a senior research officer in the International Monetary Fund (IMF) Research Department:
“Britain imposed its first Green Belt in 1955 and now, if re-zoned for building, farmland at the built edge of London has an 800-fold mark-up. There was no secular trend in housing land prices in Britain until the mid-1950s, but after Green Belts were imposed real prices increased some 15-fold. More than houses because you can substitute land out of house production. There is a similar pattern in Canada, New Zealand or the West and East coasts of the United States where policies restrict land supply.”
It's true, and some politicians try to hide behind this, that agglomeration effects in successful cities also provide upward pressure on housing costs (in simple terms people can move to a place faster than you can build homes to accommodate them). But when the gap between population growth and housing supply growth is negative for decades - as is the case in places like London and San Francisco - the result is utterly unaffordable housing. The case against urban containment boundaries, at least in terms of its effect on housing costs, is now as uncontestable as the case against rent controls.

One policy response popular with mayors (and local government in general, at least in the UK) is to argue that the problem isn't that we're not building enough houses but rather that we're building too many of the wrong sort of housing - expensive homes for rich people and especially rich overseas investors. The solution proposed - and the UK's Chartered Institute of Housing rather egregiously supports this - is that enormous amounts of government subsidy, £146 billion they say in the UK, can be used to build homes "to rent or buy through shared ownership".

Now it's probably true that the UK needs 1.45 million new homes building but is it really the case that the only way to do this is through a huge programme of, in effect, building council houses? Yes we need social housing because there are always going to be people who can't afford the rent for whatever reason (and paying full market rates in the private sector is expensive) but the gap in our housing markets isn't social housing but market housing - people who would like to buy a house (like their parents probably did) are unable to do so:
“The cost of a middle class lifestyle has increased faster than inflation. Housing, for example, makes up the largest single spending item for middle-income households, at around one third of disposable income, up from a quarter in the 1990s. House prices have been growing three times faster than household median income over the last two decades.”
While lots of other things from transport to food have been getting relatively less expensive, housing has headed in the opposite direction. Why? Because government has artificially constrained the supply of land, set down an ever more involved obstacle course for developers - just today the UK government added some new hoops, and made the process of buying and selling expensive through taxation and regulation. It's not that all these limitations are unnecessary but that that combining heavy regulation with a deliberately constrained supply can only result in higher housing costs.

The problem is that reforming urban containment policies and green belts is seen as political suicide. Even though I spent more time at planning committees arguing in favour of green belt development, the immediate and visceral response of the people I represented for all those years is still "no we don't want any more houses building". Since the logic of abolishing green belts is not politically possible (even though there are plenty of other protections for places we consider important environmentally, ecologically or in terms of heritage) we have to ask how we improve the availability of land in and around successful towns and cities.

The first option would be to review the reasons why we have green belts - this could be a national review conducted under public enquiry terms with the aim of deciding the principles for a green belt. The five purposes currently are pretty clear but we might want to consider the weight given to the policy - at the moment there is a presumption that there won't be any development unless that development has no impact or else literally cannot go somewhere else (e.g. a quarry). The simplest reform here would be to argue that housing need gets greater weight than green belt, a process that would provide more incentive for councils to allocate land rather than rely on strict green belt interpretations to save them from public opprobrium.

The second outcome of a review could be that the size of green belts could be limited - this could allow for the continued prevention of merging between communities, for example, but allow for more flexible development on the fringes of existing built-up areas (e.g a buffer zone where small scale development is permitted).

A further change might be to look at how housing development is used as a political campaigning lever - by every political party. We could consider, for example, applying the same strictures to representation on planning applications as apply to representations for licencing. Only those people directly affected by a proposed license - essentially immediate neighbours - can make representation to the licencing authority. Furthermore, local councillors and MPs can only make representations in support of someone directly affected. Applying something similar to planning would make organised campaigns against development - especially smaller scale developments - less powerful and would reduce pressure on planners and planning committees while protecting the rights of adjacent property owners.

The biggest weakness in our current planning system is the local plan process. Just consider that Bradford started preparing its local plan in 2008 and still, eleven years later, does not have a completed plan with land allocations. And this is not unique, two of Bradford neighbours (Kirklees and Calderdale) don't have a plan in place and Leeds is driving a coach and horses through theirs by changing the assessment of housing need (aka "the housing numbers"). Elsewhere local plans - even given the legal 'duty to cooperate' - are drawn up on small geographies with scant regard for the needs of neighbours and where one council (Stevenage, for example) can only meet housing need using allocations in neighbouring councils the result is a long-running political scrap.

A reform here might be to lift the planning process (as opposed to the development management system dealing with day-to-day planning applications) up to a county level, make it much more strategic and 'broad brush' and rely on the National Planning Policy Framework (NPPF) and existing land protections and regulations such as AONB (Area of Outstanding Natural Beauty) and flood plain controls to deal with the detail. The expectations on evidence and precision in the current local plan system inevitably leads to delay and also means that most of the time plans are out-of-date by the time they're published.

Our planning system serves us badly but has become - especially around green belts and in the way it makes developers ask for permission - something of a sacred cow. It is time, however, to recognise that it's not enough to keep saying we need lots more housing but then keep responding to essentially NIMBY arguments and refuse developments. Which brings me to my last suggestion one that I've wanted to happen since private pressure on John Prescott resulted in him preventing the redevelopment of Odsal Stadium in Bradford despite universal local support for the development. We should remove the power of the Secretary of State to overturn the decision of a planning inspector or the decision of a local council - this stops egregious backroom lobbying by MPs and gives us the confidence that decisions really are based on the regulations that parliament has approved.

....