Cullingworth nestles in Yorkshire's wonderful South Pennines where I once was the local councillor. These are my views - on politics, food, beer and the stupidity of those who want to tell me what to think or do. And a little on mushrooms.
Showing posts with label Vietnam. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Vietnam. Show all posts
Thursday, 2 November 2017
Trust me, I'm a politician...
There's a section in the Vietnam War documentary currently showing on BBC4 (watch if you can) where they're reporting on the fall out from the Pentagon Papers leak and the realisation that Kennedy and LBJ had lied through their teeth to the American people. We now know, and lots of Americans suspected at the time, that Richard Nixon lied through his teeth about Vietnam too.
There's a marine veteran speaking to camera who says something along the lines that, prior to the Pentagon Papers, people instinctively trusted the President and his advisors on matters of great importance - war, peace, life, death. Afterwards no-one trusted politicians - the assumption was that all of us lied.
It seems to me that this simple observation from a former soldier summed up the long-term political effect of Vietnam for the USA. For all the winning and losing, elections and campaigns, there is a grumbling view that underneath it all they're probably lying about something. And are prepared to lie about everything up to and including sending young men to the other side of the earth to get killed. So much of what we see played out today in US politics reflects this moment - from low turnouts in elections through endless rounds of campaigning funding reforms to the current suggestions of sinister conspiracy involving Russians, Facebook and shadowy data companies.
For us in Britain, we had to wait a while longer for this epiphany of lies. When Tony Blair stood in Parliament to argue for us to back a US invasion of Iraq, most of us believed that no Prime Minister would bend and warp the evidence - in effect lie - in order to get parliament to back a war. Yet that is what happened, we backed a war because we believed it when Blair said the threat was real, urgent and significant. There are a lot of people who, like that Vietnam veteran from 1971, had the scales fall from our eyes as we realised that, yes, our politicians were prepared to see men die on the basis of deliberate misinformation.
Our politics is better and worse for this epiphany. Better because the public are less prepared to take their leaders simply on trust when it comes to big and important decisions. Although some of the 'wanting to know' around Brexit is little more than spoiling, the public's support for wanting to know is because, frankly, they don't trust politicians not to sell us down the river.
Politics is worse, however, because decent and honest politicians aren't believed - and most politicians, despite the epiphany of lies, are decent and honest. Worse still, politics becomes even more shallow and unpleasant because the media, reflecting public distrust, treats politicians as dodgy, something to be exposed rather than as a set of folk wrestling with getting the right policies and with making the right decisions.
Every time I see Alistair Campbell on telly, in the papers or Tweeting, I want to scream that he was the warped spider sat in the centre of a web of lies - 'spin' they called it - that resulted in hundreds of dead British troops and untold thousands of dead Iraqis. All done to indulge Tony Blair's desire to be America's best buddy. There is no going back, in most folks' minds politicians will forever be liars and deceivers. Most of us aren't, lying's too much like hard work but, because of men like Kennedy, Nixon and Blair, people start with the opinion that we are. Trust me on this, I'm a politician.
....
Thursday, 21 September 2017
Quote of the day: Vietnam
This is spot on:
The Vietnam War was the greatest U.S. military catastrophe of the 20th century. A conflict begun under false pretenses, based on ignorance and hubris, it killed 58,000 Americans and as many as 3 million Vietnamese. It ended in utter failure. Never in our history have so many lives been wasted on such monumental futility.
My generation (and those a year or so older who sang peace and love) associate the disaster of Vietnam with Richard Nixon - it sort of suits the more lefty-minded for it to be a shockingly corrupt Republican President who shoulders the blame for this awful war. Truth is that the origins of the problem* - at least as far as US involvement is concerned - rests rather with the sainted John F Kennedy.
I've always taken the view that, far from being some blessed individual, Kennedy was as committed to projecting US power as any Republican. Kennedy's knack was to wrap it up in the promotion of democracy rather than the less appealing and blunted cold war rhetoric of Republicans like Eisenhower and Nixon.
*Interestingly the "strategic hamlet" approach developed by the French and US advisors whereby radicalised communities were relocated into controllable locations was a straight lift from the policy used by the British in Malaya. The main difference was that the Malay insurgency was by ethnic Chinese making it far easier to isolate the community hiding guerrillas and terrorists.
Saturday, 5 October 2013
The 20th Century's greatest military leader...
****
I have an academic interest in South East Asia (and the degree to prove it) plus a fascination with the strategy and tactics of warfare. Vo Nguyen Giap was, without question, the finest military leader of the 20th century.
It's also fair to say that Giap didn't merely liberate Vietnam but, by that act, he changed the politics of America. Some would say that popular disapproval combined with military defeat changed the USA's very culture.
However, in all the remembering of Vietnam, in all the discussion of the great victory at Dien Bien Phu, we miss the other service Giap did for us - he (and the Vietnamese army) finally ended the ambitions of China to control Indo-China. For all the bungling and ineptitude of the People's Liberation Army, Giap yet again demonstrated his brilliance and his army's willingness to take sacrifice.
I'm not sure the great powers have quite shaken off their arrogance and dismissal of troops and military leadership in other places. I would advise reading Giap's biography and understanding that what drove him wasn't hatred or ideology but a simple desire to be free. Free from French colonial rule, free from US occupation and free from Chinese invasion.
In the end liberty does tend to triumph.
...
People should not be overawed by the power of modern weapons ... It is the value of human beings that in the end will decide victory.
Gen. Vo Nguyen Giap
I have an academic interest in South East Asia (and the degree to prove it) plus a fascination with the strategy and tactics of warfare. Vo Nguyen Giap was, without question, the finest military leader of the 20th century.
...on Christmas Eve 1944 he and a band of 33 partisans armed with knives and flintlock rifles attacked two isolated French outposts. Thirty years later, with the French gone and the U.S.-backed South Vietnamese forces now near collapse, his army was the world's third largest, numbering 800,000. Through three decades of war, he was his nation's supreme military commander, a service record with few, if any, parallels in modern times.
It's also fair to say that Giap didn't merely liberate Vietnam but, by that act, he changed the politics of America. Some would say that popular disapproval combined with military defeat changed the USA's very culture.
However, in all the remembering of Vietnam, in all the discussion of the great victory at Dien Bien Phu, we miss the other service Giap did for us - he (and the Vietnamese army) finally ended the ambitions of China to control Indo-China. For all the bungling and ineptitude of the People's Liberation Army, Giap yet again demonstrated his brilliance and his army's willingness to take sacrifice.
I'm not sure the great powers have quite shaken off their arrogance and dismissal of troops and military leadership in other places. I would advise reading Giap's biography and understanding that what drove him wasn't hatred or ideology but a simple desire to be free. Free from French colonial rule, free from US occupation and free from Chinese invasion.
In the end liberty does tend to triumph.
...
Friday, 26 October 2012
...a reminder of neo-conservatism's curse
****
Neo-Conservatism, bastard child of the ghastly Kennedy administration in the USA, has a lot to answer for and this is a reminder:
Those who know the subject of my first degree will understand that this story - the terrible catastrophe of Vietnam - really matters to me. Sadly America repeated the mistake - in Afghanistan, in Iraq, in Libya.
Pray god (if there is one still watching) that America won't make the same mistake in Syria or Iran. Or anywhere else for that matter.
....
Neo-Conservatism, bastard child of the ghastly Kennedy administration in the USA, has a lot to answer for and this is a reminder:
...on the death of George McGovern. The best thing you (Wall Street Journal) could find to say about him is that later in life he learned about the burdens of government regulation of business. But many conservatives and libertarians who love the free market as much as you do also value and praise him for his opposition to the ultimately pointless war in Vietnam. The war was an indirect cause of inflation, price controls and, most importantly, the loss of life of too many Americans (and Vietnamese) of my generation.
Those who know the subject of my first degree will understand that this story - the terrible catastrophe of Vietnam - really matters to me. Sadly America repeated the mistake - in Afghanistan, in Iraq, in Libya.
Pray god (if there is one still watching) that America won't make the same mistake in Syria or Iran. Or anywhere else for that matter.
....
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)